If you are looking for something dark and mysterious but filled with passion and love, reading a Gothic romance novel will be the perfect choice for you.
But what is Gothic romance?
Gothic romance can mean many things. It ranges from the Brontë sisters to the dark academia romances of recent years or even straight-up horror. Sometimes it’s spicy, sometimes it’s…well, Jane Austen. But this versatility is exactly what makes the genre even more exciting.
So, in this article, I tried to include diverse picks from several centuries and with different ratios of “gothic” and “romance” so that everybody can find the perfect fit for themselves.
Here are some of the best gothic romances you’ll ever read…
Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Abuse, death, violence, racism (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
Everyone has heard of Wuthering Heights. It's one of the most popular Gothic romance books out there, but I feel like I must tune in and spread the word because this book is a masterpiece.
If you don't really read classics but you love gothic vibes, this book might be a good starting point for you. It has a strong focus on the relationships between the characters and the tragic tale of a dysfunctional family through the decades, combined with the dark and moody atmosphere of the Yorkshire moors.
Catherine and Heathcliff are definitely among the most famous tragic lovers (emphasis on tragic), but other than that, the narration itself is also genius. The book is narrated from the perspective of different (potentially unreliable) narrators, each with their own background knowledge and prejudices, so we actually never get one “accurate” version of what happened and why.
The characters in this book are often unlikable, but you still find yourself rooting for a happy ending even though you know it'll be bittersweet at best.
Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen
Spice Rating: It’s Jane Austen
Yet another popular pick, but I feel like Northanger Abbey is often on these types of lists for the wrong reason. It's an obvious satire of Gothic novels and more of a romantic coming-of-age story.
The protagonist, Catherine Morland, is an avid reader of the aforementioned novels, though, and maybe she takes them just a little too seriously. She is very naïve, and when she meets the young Henry Tilney, after a series of misunderstandings, she comes to the conclusion that she must be in a Gothic novel herself.
There's a spooky old mansion, the mysterious death of Henry’s mother, and a potential secret in the Tilney family. Of course, there's always a logical explanation for everything and a happy ending, and Tilney is one of the best love interests in an Austen novel.
I would recommend reading Northanger Abbey, either if you're already familiar with the genre, because you can appreciate the references more, or if you are just getting into early Gothic novels, because it gives you a basic idea of what to expect while making fun of it. You shouldn't take it in bad faith, though: no genre is perfect.
A Dreadful Splendor by B.R. Myers
Spice Rating: Really low, close to nothing
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Violence, suicide (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
If you like Gothic romance and you're also into whimsical murder mysteries with a crazy plot, A Dreadful Splendor might be the perfect book for you.
The main character, Genevieve, is a (fake) spiritualist in Victorian London who is tasked to perform a séance for Lord Pemberton, whose bride died under mysterious circumstances. They say it was suicide, but he's suspicious. He's also well aware that all Genevieve does is an act – he just needs her “performance” to find the killer.
The pair starts to plan the perfect deception, but it soon turns out that it may not be necessary as a number of mysterious incidents occur at the manor.
A Dreadful Splendor is not as scary as some of the other books, although it does get more serious at times, and the romance is also a lot more understated. What I loved most about it was the atmosphere, and it'll be the perfect read for lovers of the whodunnit who also like spooky ghost stories and Gothic vibes.
The Hacienda by Isabel Cañas
Spice Rating: 🌶️ (Extra Mild)
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Death, murder, racism (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
As the title may imply, The Hacienda goes beyond the stereotypical British countryside and sets the story in Mexico after the War of Independence. I would say this is a spooky story set in a very intriguing historical context.
Beatriz’s life is turned upside down, and her only hope is marrying her suitor, Don Rodolfo, whose first wife mysteriously died. After arriving at her new husband’s manor, Beatriz realizes that something evil is haunting the manor.
At first, it seems that she is all alone: her husband is gone, and his sister also dismisses her fears. Her only hope is a young priest, Padre Andrés, and the two team up to fight the darkness living in the house. The story includes both of their POV, so we also get a glimpse of both of their inner thoughts and backgrounds, which is always a great element in a novel like this.
This book is scary. I would even go as far as to classify it as horror, but it definitely has a lot of Gothic themes and tropes, most obviously, the haunted house. It's also a forbidden love story, but more on the laid-back side, so don't expect too much lust.
This book is often compared to Mexican Gothic and Rebecca– and rightfully so (if, for some mysterious reason, you have not heard about these books, you can take this as additional recs).
My Cousin Rachel by Daphne du Maurier
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️ (Extra Mild - Mild)
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Death, domestic and emotional abuse (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
My Cousin Rachel is told from the perspective of Philip Ashley, an orphaned young man who was raised by his unmarried older cousin, Ambrose, with whom he has a great relationship, and Ambrose even names him as his heir.
When Philip is already an adult, his cousin unexpectedly marries a mysterious woman and dies not long afterwards. Philip is understandably upset and suspicious and sets out to meet this mysterious woman known as Cousin Rachel. Despite all his efforts, he falls in love with the terrible thought of Rachel murdering his beloved cousin.
Daphne du Maurier is yet another Gothic romance icon, halfway between the “classics” and the contemporary. Her most popular novel is probably Rebecca (mentioned above), which is also a great one, but I decided to include My Cousin Rachel because it’s just as good, and it absolutely has those dark, thrilling vibes we all love about this genre.
This novel has the perfect atmosphere, tension, twists and turns, and a complex love story with guilt and lust that will haunt you for a long time.
A Stitch in Time by Kelley Armstrong
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️ (Extra Mild - Medium)
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Death, murder (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
This book has everything that a good Gothic romance needs and more. A haunted British manor, murders, a protagonist who's able to see ghosts, and also time-traveling... Yes, you read that right.
As a child in the mysterious Thorne Manor, Bronwyn Dale could see ghosts. But as an adult, she's convinced that it was just her imagination, including the boy from 200 years ago, with whom she became friends.
When Bronwyn returns 20 years later, the boy, William, now a grown-up man, is still there, but he's not happy. Of course, things get romantic after a while, but this isn't the whole story. Thorne Manor is full of ghosts, and after a series of mysterious disappearances, everybody is a suspect, and Bronwyn has to get to the bottom of it all.
This book is really spooky and scary, but the romance also works surprisingly well, especially considering that the two protagonists literally have 200 years between each other... The fact that one of them is a dreamy Victorian Lord probably helps.
Plain Bad Heroines by Emily M. Danforth
Spice Rating:🌶️🌶️🌶️ (Medium)
If you're into multiple timelines, sapphic romance, mysteries, movies, and celebrities, look no further.
Plain Bad Heroines has two timelines, with one set in a Rhode Island private school in 1902, and the other in the LA film industry in the present. The boarding school storyline follows Flo and Clara, who are obsessed with, well, each other, and another young woman, Mary MacLane, and her memoir. They are the ones who founded the titular Plain Bad Heroines Society. There, they meet in secret, but it soon turns into a tragedy. Their corpses are found together with Mary’s book, and soon afterwards, the school closes its doors forever.
In the present, their story is turned into a book and then a horror movie adaptation starring a celebrity actor, Harper Harper, and a former child star, Audrey Wells. There's basically a celebrity love triangle going on, combined with the horror element, and while the present storyline, of course, has less gothic vibes than the 1902 plot, they're definitely still there.
This book is a strange combination of gothic horror, celebrity horror comedy, and a queer love story, but somehow, the author makes it work. Don't be put off by the fact that it's a bit on the longer side (over 600 pages), I promise it's worth reading.
Nocticadia by Keri Lake
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ (Medium - Hot)
Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):
Murder, sexual assault, abuse, torture, explicit sexuality, age gap (this list might not cover all content covered in the book, please do your own research before reading this book)
Nocticadiais the perfect combination of dark academia and Gothic romance, telling a chilling story of forbidden love with the elite setting, secret societies, and intrigue.
This book follows Lilia, who gets accepted to the Ivy League-esque Dracadia University. That's where she meets Devryck Bramwell, aka Doctor Death, a strange professor who operates a midnight lab. Lilia decided to become involved because she suspects that the strange disease Professor Bramwell is investigating might explain the mysterious death of her mother.
The romance between the two main characters is definitely slow-burn, with tragic backstories but also with a fair amount of spice. Devryck Bramwell is a sarcastic, dark, and very smart love interest, and the author managed to make the scientific aspect surprisingly interesting.
This book has a student-teacher romance, but it's also full of mystery and danger (and a really creepy disease), and although it's relatively long in terms of page count, once things get going, you'll devour it in no time.
There are so many amazing gothic romance novels out there to choose from. Although this subgenre of romance has been around for centuries, there are always new stories to tell and to love. I hope I helped you find your next favorite - happy reading!
Want to read more books in this genre? Join the waitlist for OwlCrate’s new quarterly Romance subscription, coming in Spring 2025!
Every 3 months, subscribers will get an OwlCrate exclusive edition of a signed, newly released hardcover Romance novel with incredible design elements. Plus, as a subscriber, you will get first access to beautiful limited editions of popular Romance books.
The Nest App
⚪️ The app is 100% free and all are welcome!
⚪️ Created for the bookish community and powered by OwlCrate!
⚪️ We have exclusive live events always happening in The Nest, so download the app and join the community today!
























