By Frawst

For other readers who are anything like me, opening a classic story or fairy tale can bring immense joy. Revisiting these stories feels like catching up with an old friend. But sometimes we desire new twists on old tales, and some of us love those twists to have some queerness in them.


From a nonbinary plague doctor to sapphic awakening vampires, and many other variations, these twelve queer retellings of classics and fairy tales are sure to delight every type of reader

Horror Retellings Of Classic Novels

Hungerstone by Kat Dunn

"To be a woman is a horror I can little comprehend."

Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️ /🌶️ (2.5) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

blood, gore, death, misogyny, infidelity, infertility, death of a parent, toxic relationship, emotional abuse, gaslighting, sexism, body horror, injury, domestic abuse, suicidal thoughts, grief, eating disorder

Hungerstone takes the story of Carmilla, a vampire fiction novel that predates Dracula, and gives us a sapphic romance retelling full of vampires. In this retelling, though, Lenore experiences a queer awakening. 


Over the last ten years, Lenore's and Henry's childless marriage has not been particularly happy. While on their way to a country home, the pair comes across a woman during a storm and ends up taking her home with them. What transpires is an awakening in Lenore as she falls for the mysterious (and gothic vampire) Carmilla.


The atmosphere of this gothic horror reminds us that while the characters might be dead, the genre is thriving. Creepiness abounds as Kat Dunn weaves her tale with the finest of languages, culminating in a finale that you can't look away from.

Off With Their Heads by Zoe Hana Mikuta

"Once upon a time, in a Saint-stricken world, there were two horrible girls in love…"

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

gore, body horror, toxic relationship, animal death, abandonment, death of a parent, child death, confinement

Everyone knows Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glassand What Alice Found There by Lewis Carroll. To borrow a quote from the original, 'We're all mad' here describes Off With Their Heads so well that the quote is used on the book's cover. 


This Korean-inspired retelling introduces us to Carousel (Caro) Rabbit and Iccadora (Icca) Alice Sickle, two witches who were once in love with each other. We follow the pair after they're sentenced to the grotesque and evil Wonderland woods for a crime they didn't commit, and along the way, we watch the two as they manage to break each other's hearts.


Zoe Hana Mikuta elevates her sapphic horror story with moments that will leave you wanting to cover your eyes (or ears), while peeking through to see what transpires next. Her prose, which reads like poetry, lends itself to creepiness as much as evil saints and things that lurk around each corner.

Horror Retellings Of Fairy Tales

Not Good for Maidens by Tori Bovalino

"For just a moment, she could pretend that her own nails were claws, that the lingering taste of blood came from her own mouth. That she was strong and unbreakable and invincible, not weak and fragile and human."

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

gore, body horror, blood, torture, confinement, kidnapping, cannibalism, alcohol, death

Lou is just your typical ace teenager who doesn't quite feel like she fits in with her family in Not Good for Maidens. But when her best friend, her teenage Aunt Neela, goes missing, Lou embarks on a family journey she never expected.


Weaving original elements of Rossetti's Goblin Market (and Simon and Garfunkel's 'Scarborough Fair'), Tori Bovolino interconnects events from Lou's mother and other aunt seventeen years ago with those of the present day. The goblins have taken Neela, and it's up to the three other women to rescue her. 


With a sapphic romance and bisexual representation too, the  body horror and gritty details work together and leave you wondering if you should run or maybe stay for just a few more minutes. After all, the goblin market can't be that bad, right?

The Salt Grows Heavy by Cassandra Khaw

"It is always interesting to see how often women are described as ravenous when it is the men who, without exception, take without thought of compensation."

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

body horror, gore, child death, cannibalism, fire/fire injury, domestic abuse, pregnancy, miscarriage, animal death, confinement

When people think of The Little Mermaid, they think of someone so in love with a prince that she gave up her voice. But what if the stories got it wrong? Instead, the prince kidnaps a mermaid and forces her to eat her tongue, but the prince is then devoured by their shared offspring. Mermaids, after all, have teeth and claws and the ability to consume whole kingdoms in The Salt Grows Heavy.


The mermaid and her nonbinary Plague Doctor are on the run, having escaped the despair wrought by her children. With their own darkness within them, they slowly learn more about each other and fall in love. They come across saints, and children abused and killed for religious reasons, and a mermaid determined to save them along with her Plague Doctor. 


The words used may cause visceral reactions, but Cassandra Khaw knows how to spellbind us with this horror-filled fairytale retelling of The Little Mermaid.

Romance Retellings Of Classic Novels

Most Ardently by Gabe Cole Novoa

"The warmth in his father's face alone made Oliver misty-eyed all over again. 'I know you didn't tell me perhaps the way you'd imagined, but I'm so glad to know you, son. No matter what, I will always fight for you."

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

Transphobia, deadnaming, dysphoria, homophobia, outing, sexism, suicidal thoughts, stalking, classism

Take everything loved about Pride & Prejudice, but with Elizabeth Bennett replaced by a transmasc person named Oliver. 


Oliver just wants to survive and not be forced to marry and be a wife. After meeting Mr. Darcy as 'Elizabeth' (Oliver's deadname), even though the two don't initially get along, Oliver finds that he can be his authentic self around Mr. Darcy more and more.


Oliver feels more and more trapped as the threat of marriage looms closer, but maybe, just maybe, he can find happiness as Oliver with Mr. Darcy.


This story contains every beat of the classic novel fans expect, while making the story unique with a character who simply wants to live authentically as himself. 

Finley Embraces Heart & Home by Anyta Sunday

"I’d love to absorb you in every way, and I’d love to play with your hair, read your eyes, feel disarmed in your presence. I’d love to experience a seizure of full-silenced tenderness with you."

Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ (4) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

homophobia

Finley is not excited about moving into a McMansion with his new stepfather. After his father died, Finley got used to the life of him and his mother in their poorer neighborhood. Plus, he's pretty sure his stepfather doesn't like him and is homophobic, so his enthusiasm levels dip below zero. 


When Finley meets his stepbrother, though, his opinions slowly change, even if his stepfather wants to keep his son away from Finley and his gayness.


As the two stepbrothers slowly fall in love, they have to navigate homophobia, distance, and the knowledge that this could irrevocably change their lives and outside relationships. 


Mansfield Park gets a makeover in Finley Embraces Heart and Home, with two male love interests in the modern era. Plus moments that cause you to laugh, cry, and perhaps even yell at Finley's stepfather.

Romance Retellings Of Fairy Tales

Her Princess at Midnight by Erica Ridley

"Cynthia couldn’t care less about the prince. Her eyes dazzled and her stomach filled with butterflies at the sight of the resplendent Princess Ammalia…whose black-lashed, bright blue gaze had just locked with Cynthia’s."

Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️ (3) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

domestic abuse, emotional abuse, physical abuse, grief

Meet Cynthia, the unloved stepsister forced to a life of servitude, drudgery, and no escape in sight. One day, when she spots the royal procession, while her stepsisters swoon over the prince, she makes eye contact with the Princess, Ammalia. Imagine her surprise when the princess ends up at her house, and suddenly Cynthia is waited upon by her family at the princess's order.


Her Princess at Midnight has a happily ever after that will leave you swooning. This retelling foregoes a fairy godmother and instead allows Cynthia to rescue herself with the help of the princess. Expect to cheer throughout this novella.

Queen Takes Rose by Katee Robert

"If we both fell for our enemies, what does that make us? Really smart? Or really foolish?” “Ah, Aurora.” Hades smiles. It’s warm and soft and changes his entire face. “It makes us very, very lucky."

Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ (5) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

grief, death of a parent, violence, medical content, murder, death, war

Aurora (Sleeping Beauty) gets a modern dark romance retelling in Queen Takes Rose. Aurora has been biding her time over the last twenty years to destroy the woman who killed her mother, by signing over her freedom to Hades for safety. Malone wants two weeks with Aurora to get the blue-haired ebony beauty out of her head. 


When Hades signs Aurora over to Malone for two weeks, will she fulfill her plans of murder, or will she find herself falling for the enemy — and perhaps even sinking so completely into Malone's bones that Malone won't let her go?


With a sex club, kink, and violence, this version of Sleeping Beauty vibes more with the darker aspects of the original tale than anything Disney might show. 


Katee Robert doesn't hold back on emotions, words, or a love story you won't know whether to root for, but will either way.

Fantasy Retellings Of Classic Novels

As I Descended by Robin Talley

"Between the atheism and the lesbian thing, Lily was a terrible Catholic. Even before she'd added murder to her list of sins."

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

blood, murder, death, ableism, homophobia, slavery, car accident, animal death, confinement, suicide, outing

Take  Macbeth, add some ghosts, spirits, two gay couples, modernity, and lo, and you'll get  As I Descended 


All Maria wants is to be valedictorian and top of her class, so she and her girlfriend, Lily, can attend the same college and live together for another four years. The only person standing in her way? Delilah. 


One night, Lily and Maria decide to frame Delilah for drug use, knowing that it will ruin her future. What transpires are the main plots from Macbeth, and no less tragic.


Robin writes as though she and Shakespeare discussed how to modernize one of his most famous plays. The creepiness, the characters, and the varying points of view make up a well-rounded story you won't be able to put down until you finish reading it.

Devour the Dark by Nikki St. Crowe

"We’ve made new families, formed new friendships, but he and I are all that remain of our old life. I thought I had left that behind, but in this moment, I’m glad to have him back."

Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ /🌶️ (4.5) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

violence, blood, grief, murder, kidnapping, child abuse, child death

Peter Pan, but make it a throuple with two bisexual malesDevour the Dark, the sequel to Devourer of Men, follows Hook, Roc (the Crocodile), and Wendy Darling on their journey back to Wonderland. As they rush to save Roc, with the help of his brother, the three realize there is nothing they won't do for each other.


Nikki writes well-known characters in such a fresh way, complete with a throuple still coming to terms with how they can be in a three-person relationship. 


This refreshing take on well-known Peter Pan characters breathes new life into them. You'll squeal at every spicy scene while hoping against hope that a happily ever after is in store for the trio.

Fantasy Retellings Of Fairy Tales

The Raven and the Reindeer by T. Kingfisher

"No matter how pale and pure and perfect you are, the moon is even more perfect."

Spice Level: Zero

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

animal death, kidnapping, blood, murder, injury, violence, cannibalism, death of a parent

T. Kingfisher uses her whole arsenal of wit, charm, and humour to take you on a rescue mission in The Raven and the Reindeer, her retelling of The Snow Queen


When Gerta wakes up to see the Snow Queen kidnapping her best friend, she knows she must go and save him. Although she doesn't know how far this adventure will take her or what dangers she might face, Gerta knows nobody else will try to free him. 


Along the way, she ends up getting kidnapped by a witch, befriends a raven, and eventually uses a reindeer skin to become one. But most importantly, she falls in love with a lovely girl who joins her on her adventure.


This atmospheric and sapphic fairytale retelling leaves you smiling at how sweet Gerta is and how brave she becomes with each passing day. By the end, you'll want Gerta to succeed for herself, no matter what happens to her childhood friend.

The Darkest Part of the Forest by Holly Black

"You and your sister are very dear to each other. To show your regard, you give each other lovely bouquets of lies."

Spice Level: 🌶️ (1) - OwlCrate Spice Meter

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers):

death, animal death, violence, child abuse, injury detail, blood, homophobia, domestic abuse

The Darkest Part of the Forest gender bends Snow White. In the woods where Hazel and her elder brother Ben live, everyone knows about the fairy boy in the glass casket. 


When Hazel, without any memory, awakens the boy, their town will never be the same. With help from Jack, Ben's changeling best friend, they must battle to save their town and maybe find love along the way. 


This story offers a truly refreshing take on first love. Holly Black writes a world so uniquely hers and engaging that by closing your eyes, you'll be transported into the world within The Darkest Part of the Forest.

Plenty of queer retellings exist, and so these twelve should not be considered the only options available in libraries and bookstores. They should be used to celebrate queer voices that have been marginalized in the past. So choose a queer voice, an iced beverage, and find a pillow to spend an afternoon. Happy reading!

Frawst found the best way to process her feelings growing up was through poetry, which is why she double majored in History and English with a Creative Writing Emphasis. Writing allowed her to play with words in various orders and rhythms to express her feelings, which started in high school. When she's not reading these days, she enjoys text-based role-playing games, which, while not poetry, still allows her to write most every day.


Last year involved her reading all over the spectrum, including the 1619 Project, the Raven Boys Cycle, Nikita Gill, and a lot of dark fantasy. You can find her in Canada, usually with her nose in a book or headphones on while she writes and codes in game or gazes dreamily at the nature which surrounds her house.

Other Articles You Might Enjoy

The Nest App

⚪️ The app is 100% free and all are welcome!


⚪️ Created for the bookish community and powered by OwlCrate!


⚪️ We have exclusive live events always happening in The Nest, so  join the community today! 

Visual divider